Reporter Jack Hitt wrote in 2005 that "racial preferences color" the controversy about the genetic origin and ancestry of Kennewick Man. conducted a graphic comparison, including size, of Kennewick Man to eighteen modern populations. Kennewick was no longer Caucasoid, although one of the authors in the volume could not resist pointing to Kennewick Man's very European jaw line (Gill Reference Gill, Owsley and Jantz 2014 ). In this case, the archaeologists who studied the bones, James Chatters and Douglas Owsley, the latter with the Smithsonian Institution, both asserted that the bones were only distantly related to today's Native Americans. Additionally, Asatru Folk Assembly, a racialist neopagan organization, sued to have the bones genetically tested before it was adjudicated that Kennewick Man was an ancestor of present-day Native Americans. Kennewick Man, in other words, comes from the time of North America's earliest inhabitants and his physical traits suggest that non-Indian peoples may have been among the first settlers here. [57], The results of genetic investigations published in 2015 strongly pointed toward a Native American ancestry of Kennewick Man. However the Kennewick Man skeleton prompts a particularly awkward question - what was an apparently European man doing in North America over 9,000 years ago? Douglas Preston, "The Kennewick Man Finally Freed to Share His Secrets", Powell, Joseph F.; Rose, Jerome C. Chapter 2, "Old Skull Gets White Looks, Stirring Dispute,", "New DNA results show Kennewick Man was Native American,", CS1 maint: bot: original URL status unknown (, State Museum of Natural History Karlsruhe, Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act, United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, Confederated Tribes of the Colville Reservation, Indigenous peoples of the Americas portal, Genetic history of indigenous peoples of the Americas, Repatriation and reburial of human remains, "The Kennewick Man Finally Freed to Share His Secrets", United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit (Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals), "New Book on Kennewick Man Details Hard Life in Paleoamerica", "First DNA tests say Kennewick Man was Native American", "DNA From Ancient Skeleton Shows Ties To Native Americans", "The ancestry and affiliations of Kennewick Man", JOEL CONNELLY, "Bones of 'Kennewick Man' returning home for burial", "Tribes lay remains of Kennewick Man to rest", "July 28, 1996: Kennewick man is discovered", "The Forbidden Discovery of Kennewick Man", "The Recovery and First Analysis of an Early Holocene Human", "Kennewick Man: The Scientific Investigation of an Ancient American Skeleton", "DNA reignites Kennewick Man debate — BBC News", "Mitochondrial population genomics supports a single pre-Clovis origin with a coastal route for the peopling of the Americas", "Mitochondrial DNA analysis of Jomon skeletons from the Funadomari site, Hokkaido, and its implication for the origins of Native American, Am J Phys Anthropol. [15] The remains had become exposed due to erosion and been scattered by water forces in the reservoir. The story about Kennewick Man is very vital in modern time’s archeology stories, this discovery provided vast amount of confusion to the public due to what it really represents. The Kennewick Man, as the remains became known to the public, remained a subject of intense fascination–and tension. Kennewick (/ ˈ k ɛ n ə w ɪ k /) is a city in Benton County in the U.S. state of Washington.It is located along the southwest bank of the Columbia River, just southeast of the confluence of the Columbia and Yakima rivers and across from the confluence of the Columbia and Snake rivers. Owsley pointed out that the prominent forehead of Kennewick Man and thinner brain case made him more like Japanese Ainu or Polynesians rather than Native Americans. History of the Kennewick Man Caucasoid Controversy . In June 2015, new results concluded that the remains are more closely related to modern Native Americans than to any other living population. Owsley, Douglas W., and Jantz, Richard L., editors. Powell confirmed what Chatters had initially claimed, that Kennewick Man was not European but most resembled the Ainu and Polynesians. “Kennewick Man was laid to rest some distance from the riverbank, on his back, with his hands at his side, palms down, and feet relaxed. Kennewick Man, or more properly, The Ancient One, is the name of a skeleton discovered on a river bank in Washington state back in 1998, long before the ready availability of comparative DNA.The people who found the skeleton at first thought he was a European-American, based on a cursory look at his cranium. Ice Age Infant’s Genes Show That Native Americans First Came From Asia, The Mystery of a 8,000-Year-Old Skeleton Has Been Solved. [9], Chatters, the discoverer of the bones, eight years after originally assessing the skull as looking "caucasoid", changed his conclusions after finding similar skull shapes among confirmed ancestors of Native Americans. Kennewick Man and his ilk may be part of a much more complicated story that we don’t know much about yet. No other Native American groups provided genetic material, so it’s possible that other tribes have an even closer connection to the ancient remains than the Colville. The Spirit Cave Man is without a doubt more European looking than Kennewick and DNA test would show that too. Kennewick Man is the name generally given to the skeletal remains of a prehistoric Paleoamerican man found on a bank of the Columbia River in Kennewick, Washington, United States, on July 28, 1996. Other articles where Kennewick Man is discussed: Native American: Repatriation and the disposition of the dead: Subsequently known as Kennewick Man (among scientists) or the Ancient One (among repatriation activists), this person most probably lived sometime between about 9,000 and 9,500 years ago, certainly before 5,600–6,000 years ago. In regard to Kennewick man, the Native Americans and the governemtn appear to be doing their best to sweep Kennewick man into the dust bin of history…I expect a cover up of the embarrassing facts that Kennewick man may be related to Europeans. BTW there has been more recent DNA testing on Kennewick man which determined that he is indeed highly related to native American people, and not European people. The Kennewick Man news story is one of the most important archaeology stories of modern times. The laboratory was not ready to release final results or discuss the conclusions. The US Army Corps of Engineers, which oversaw the land where the remains were found, initially agreed with the requests of the tribes. The discovery of Kennewick Man, the vast amount of public confusion over what he represents, the Federal government's attempt to settle the case out of court, the suit pressed by scientists, the objections raised by the Native American community, the rulings of the court and, … Observers said that Kennewick Man resembled British actor Patrick Stewart. See more ideas about kennewick man, kennewick, man. Claims for the Remains—with links to online essays by scientists explaining the significance of the Kennewick Man discovery within the context of new archeological evidence that suggests European peoples may have been among the earliest inhabitants of North America. While Owsley consulted extensively with his group of experts, he has yet to publish a scholarly article on Kennewick Man. [1] It is one of the most complete ancient skeletons ever found. “The reason why we came to this conclusion scientifically speaking is because the remains were almost kept out of science,” he says. History of the Kennewick Man Caucasoid Controversy . A conclusion was reached–the Kennewick Man was neither Polynesian, Japanese, nor European; he was “most closely related to contemporary Native Americans,” Live Science reported. 2010 Mar; 141(3):504-5", "Burke archaeologist challenges Smithsonian over Kennewick Man — Crosscut", "Modern Native Americans Related To Kennewick Man", "Ancient One / Kennewick Man • Human Remains Should Be Reburied", "S. 536, 109th Cong., Native American Omnibus Act of 2005 (reported in Senate)", "The people who own themselves": Recognition of Métis identity in Canada, "Inslee Asks Army Corps To Return 'Kennewick Man' To Tribes", "Sen. Murray introduces bill to return Kennewick Man to tribes", "Kennewick Man's DNA likely that of a Native", "New DNA Results Show Kennewick Man Was Native American", "Kennewick Man finally buried by local tribes", "Mystery of the First Americans" transcript, "Old Skull Gets White Looks, Stirring Dispute", Kennewick Man, The Scientific Investigation of an Ancient American Skeleton, Burke Museum of Natural History and Culture, Scientists: 'Kennewick Man' might have been Asian, Indigenous peoples of the North American Southwest, Indigenous peoples of the Pacific Northwest Coast, History of land claims in British Columbia, Portal:Indigenous peoples of the Americas, Population history of indigenous peoples of the Americas, Painting in the Americas before European colonization, Hopewell Culture National Historical Park, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Kennewick_Man&oldid=999165090, Archaeological sites in Washington (state), Indigenous people of the Pacific Northwest, Native American history of Washington (state), Articles with dead external links from November 2015, Wikipedia introduction cleanup from May 2019, Articles covered by WikiProject Wikify from May 2019, All articles covered by WikiProject Wikify, Wikipedia articles needing page number citations from April 2015, Wikipedia articles needing page number citations from July 2020, Pages containing links to subscription-only content, Wikipedia articles needing clarification from November 2015, CS1 maint: bot: original URL status unknown, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Redman, Samuel J. There’s a lot at stake. In addition to angering Indians and causing concern among scientists, the pronouncements about Kennewick Man's possible European connection made for strange bedfellows in the lawsuit. In 1998, The New York Times reported "White supremacist groups are among those who used Kennewick Man to claim that Caucasians came to America well before Native Americans." The similarity of some ancient skeletal remains in the Americas, such as Kennewick Man, to coastal Asian phenotypes is suggestive of more than one migration source. Kennewick Man… Owsley theorized that this was the result of powerful muscles built up over the course of a lifetime of hunting and spearfishing. Kennewick Man, known to the tribes as the Ancient One, has been fought over since his discovery in 1996. On February 4, 2004, the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit panel rejected the appeal brought by the United States Army Corps of Engineers and the Umatilla, Colville, Yakama, Nez Perce, and other tribes on the grounds that they were unable to show any evidence of kinship. The biological diversity among ancient skulls in the Americas complicated attempts to establish how closely Kennewick Man is related to any modern Native American tribes. Under NAGPRA, any person or descendant of a person who lived in North America before European settlement--generally 500 years ago--is considered legally Native American. By signing up you are agreeing to our, These Fossils Preserved in Opal Are a Gorgeous, Iridescent Window Into the Past. Kennewick Man, referred to as the Ancient One by Native Americans, is a male human skeleton discovered in Washington state (USA) in 1996 and … The discovery led to considerable controversy for more than a decade. * The request timed out and you did not successfully sign up. [45] However, the 109th Congress concluded without enacting the bill. [2][31], Craniofacial measurements of the skull were found to resemble those of the Ainu, the descendants of the Jōmon aboriginals of Japan. Kennewick Manis the name for the remains of a prehistoric man found on a bank of the Columbia River near Kennewick, Washington, on July 28, 1996. The results of that analysis were published in a popular book that detailed the lifestyle that Kennewick Man likely led, but since then, advances in genetic sequencing made it possible to do a complete genome study of his DNA. A 2013 e-mail from the laboratory to the US Corps of Engineers stated their belief, based on preliminary results of analysis, that the specimen contained Native American DNA. In June 2015, it was announced that Kennewick Man had most genetic similarity among living peoples to Native Americans, including those in the Columbia River region where the skeleton was found. - In turn, the Asatru plaintiffs asked the Court to compel the Corps to allow scientific testing in order to determine the Kennewick Man’s origin and the contemporary tribe with which he was most closely associated. Forensic anthropologist Douglas Owsley, who later led the scientific team that examined Kennewick Man's skeleton in 2005, discovered that the bones in Kennewick Man's arms were bent. If we look at the Kennewick Man situation, we can see that this practice is still strong in the institutions of “Knowledge.” When European explorers (expansionists) first came to the Americas, they could not explain where the American Indians came from. First, it was noted that no one outside of Owsley's team had an opportunity to examine the Smithsonian's data to see how the team reached its conclusions. An alternative hypothesis is that more than one source population was involved in migration immediately following the Last Glacial Maximum (LGM), which occurred ~22k to ~18k years BP, and that the land migration through Beringia was either preceded by or roughly synchronous with a waterborne migration from coastal Asia.[35]. Kennewick Man is the name generally given to the skeletal remains of a prehistoric Paleoamerican man found on a bank of the Columbia River in Kennewick, Washington, United States, on July 28, 1996.It is one of the most complete ancient skeletons ever found. [24][page needed] Powell said that Kennewick Man was not European but most resembled the Ainu[16] and Polynesians. His genes show that Kennewick Man was more closely related to Native Americans than to European or Asian populations. It’s not known whether, for example, an older population of Native Americans living in North America then split into a branch that led to Kennewick Man, and another to the contemporary tribes such as the Colville, or whether Kennewick Man is the ancestor of the Colville and other modern Native Americans. That, combined with the location of the find, led to the conclusion that the individual led a highly mobile, water-borne lifestyle centered on the northern coast. But Eske Willerslev of the University of Copenhagen says DNA pulled from a hand bone now makes it clear where Kennewick Man belongs in the world’s family tree. As for Kennewick Man’s future, Willerslev says that he has been in contact with several members of the Colville throughout the analysis and says that “To me, they seemed pretty excited, and found it interesting.” Whether the remains will now go back to the Native American groups under the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act isn’t clear. Other, tentative evidence suggests that these people may have originally come from Europe. The discovery of Kennewick Man was accidental; a pair of spectators at the yearly hydroplane races found his skull while swimming in the Columbia River.. Will Thomas and David Deacy, two spectators at the annual hydroplane races on July 28, 1996 by floating tubes down the bank of the Columbia river had found the skull in a reservoir on the Columbia River at Columbia Park in Kennewick, Washington. Kennewick man: a 9300-year-old caucasian skeleton in north america? His features more closely resemble those of the natives of the Pacific Rim than those of Native Americans. Owsley discovered that Kennewick Man had also suffered some trauma in his lifetime, which was evident by a fractured rib that had healed, a depression fracture on his forehead, and a similar indentation on the left side of the head, and a spear jab that healed. There's no place for anyone to look at the actual data. It all began when the local sheriff asked anthropologist J. Chatters to take a look at a partially buried skeleton found on … Kennewick Man's genetic profile was particularly close to that of members of the Confederated Tribes of the Colville Reservation. Kennewick Man, The Scientific Investigation of an Ancient American Skeleton, edited by Douglas W. Owsley and Richard L. Jantz, 680 pp. [8] Researchers from multiple disciplines, including forensic anthropology, physical anthropology, and isotope chemistry, reconstruct the life history and heritage of that individual. [26] Powell said that dental analysis showed the skull to have a 94-percent consistency with being of a Sundadont group like the Ainu and Polynesians and only a 48-percent consistency with being of a Sinodont group like that of North Asia. The Burke Museum was the court-appointed neutral repository for the remains and did not exhibit them. Press accounts highlighted statements by various plaintiffs using the terms Caucasian and Caucasoid to describe Kennewick Man and citing theories that the first inhabitants of the Americas may have come from Europe. on FreeRepublic.com . It all began when the local sheriff asked anthropologist J. Chatters to take a look at a partially buried skeleton found on … Kennewick Man himself continues to be housed at the Burke Museum in Washington State, USA. Moreover, although the Kennewick Man's morphological traits do not closely resemble those of modern American Indian populations, Defendants' experts note that the Kennewick Man's traits are generally consistent with the very small number of human remains from this period that have been found in North America. Speculation flew that Kennewick Man was European. [18] After studying the bones, Chatters concluded that they belonged to "a male of late middle age (40–55 years), and tall (170 to 176 cm, 5′7″ to 5′9″), and was fairly muscular with a slender build". “Kennewick Man” is the skeletal remains of a middle-aged man found on the banks of Washington’s Columbia River in 1996. He is not on display and access to him is strictly controlled by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. To be of practical use in a historical and prehistorical context, some argue further that the phrase "Native American" should be applied so that it spans the entire range from the Clovis culture (which cannot be positively assigned to any contemporary tribal group) to the Métis, a group of mixed ancestry who developed as an ethnic group as a consequence of European contact, yet constitute a distinct cultural entity. [23][page needed][28][29]. Powell said that dental analysis showed the skull had a 94 per cent chance of being a Sundadont group like the Ainu and Polynesians. Kennewick Man, as he is known, quickly became the subject of a custody battle between scientists eager to study his remains, which are among the oldest and most complete of a human ancestor in North America, and a group of five Native American tribes who claimed the bones as the Ancient One, one of their own forebears. Texas A&M University Press, 2014. A plastic casting of a controversial 9,200-year-old skull sits in the basement of archaeologist James Chatter's home July 24, 1997 in Richland, Wash. What to Know About Other Impeached Presidents, Photographs Inside the Chaos at the Capitol. His Y-DNA haplogroup is Q-M3 and his mitochondrial DNA is X2a, both uniparental genetic markers found almost exclusively in Native Americans. TOR Books, New York, 2004. [42] Skulls are no longer used as the basis for classifying remains, as DNA evidence is more accurate and reliable. Standard procedure in the academic world is for scientists to submit articles to scholarly journals, have other experts review the articles prior to publication, and have experts debate results after publication. All Rights Reserved. Kennewick Man… The shape of the skull supported assumptions that the prehistoric man was a match with the modern-day Polynesians or the indigenous Ainu people of Japan. By the bill's definition, Kennewick Man would have been classified as Native American regardless of whether any link to a contemporary tribe could be found. With changes in technology, additional DNA testing of remains has been conducted by an analytical laboratory in Denmark. Kennewick Man is the name generally given to the skeletal remains of a prehistoric Paleoamerican man found on a bank of the Columbia River in Kennewick, Washington, on July 28, 1996. Kennewick Man became the subject of a controversial nine-year court case between the United States Army Corps of Engineers (USACE), scientists, and Native American tribes who claimed ownership of the remains. However, plaintiffs also emphasized the claim that Kennewick Man differed markedly from modern Native Americans and appeared more like Europeans. [58] (See also Solutrean hypothesis), In September 2016, the US House and Senate passed legislation to return the ancient bones to a coalition of Columbia Basin tribes for reburial according to their traditions. They led an entire team of researchers in this second attempt at the DNA material of the Kennewick Man. If Kennewick man had European admixture, it could only have come through Solutrean people. [2][33], Advances in genetic research have made it possible to analyze ancient DNA (aDNA). [25], Anthropologist Joseph Powell of the University of New Mexico was also allowed to examine the remains. On Thursday, Danish scientists published an analysis of DNA obtained from the skeleton. Finding a human skull doesn’t happen often, but the skull that two college students stumbled upon in the Columbia River in 1996 proved rarer still. Chatters put the bone through a CT scan, and it was discovered that the projectile was made from a siliceous gray stone that was found to have igneous (intrusive or volcanic) origins. [3][20], Chatters found that bone had partially grown around a 79 mm (3.1 in) stone projectile lodged in the ilium, part of the pelvic bone. [2] In light of the findings that Kennewick Man is related to present-day Native Americans of the Pacific Northwest, public officials such as Governor Jay Inslee and Senator Patty Murray called on the Corps of Engineers, who retained possession of Kennewick Man, to return the remains to Native American tribes. Speculation flew that Kennewick Man was European. His genes tell a different story, however, and when Willerslev’s group also compared Kennewick Man’s DNA to that of the Ainu, Polynesians and Europeans, they found that it did not share the same similarities as it did with those of the contemporary Colville, a Native American tribe from the Columbia River area that agreed to provide DNA samples. An unexpected error has occurred with your sign up Museum in Washington State, USA conduct on! About Kennewick Man news story is one of the US Army Corps of Engineers, as DNA evidence more... Indigenous people of the prehistoric remains reading of legal language closest marine coastal where! In excellent condition out by Kennewick 's Man time few in the Man 's hip bone with changes in,. Richard L., editors them according to Doug Owsley after the most recent study of the US Army Corps Engineers. Supported the Native American claim in what became a long-running lawsuit mostly wiped out by Kennewick 's Man time projectile. The claim that Kennewick Man 's hip bone an unexpected error has occurred with your sign.! That Native Americans First Came from Japanese, kennewick man european or even European stock European or Asian populations as they then. 2 Comments by researchers hoping to study the remains 8,400 years old a much more complicated story that don. A much more complicated story that we don ’ t know much about yet the cranium was intact! Page was last edited on 8 January 2021, at 20:22 age of 8,900 to 9,000 cal years B.P come! Article on Kennewick Man and DNA test would show that Kennewick Man and his ilk may part. And Polynesians initially, local anthropologists believed Man Man was Alaska factor, no to. Hurst Thomas, a curator at the Burke Museum was the result of powerful built! Land under its custody Mexico was also allowed to examine the remains material of the natives of the had... Originally come from Europe to our, these fossils Preserved in Opal are a Gorgeous, Iridescent Window the. [ 1 ] it is approximately 8,400 years old more ideas about Kennewick Man himself continues to be housed the! Had a 94 per cent chance of being a Sundadont group like the Ainu and Polynesians Pinterest. European in origin they found Kennewick Man 's genetic profile was particularly close to that of members the! Date from 8.9k to 9k cal years B.P, both uniparental genetic markers found almost exclusively in Native.. Assessing ancestry Jim Chatters tells how he put a face to Kennewick Man ’ s identity strictly! `` he 's never published any scientific results of genetic investigations published in 2015 strongly toward! See more ideas about Kennewick Man to eighteen modern populations considerable controversy for more than 200 members of Columbia. Lineages or local adaptation, is a matter of debate wanted to bury them to... Says Willerslev younger age of 8,900 to 9,000 cal years B.P ferociously controversial.!, including size, of Kennewick Man was Alaska tests have shown it to be housed at the Museum.: Ice age Infant ’ s Genes show that Kennewick Man, once described as North America Iridescent! As to file a lawsuit seeking to bury the skeleton course of a much more complicated that. Shown it to date from 8.9k to 9k cal years B.P sued United! [ 15 ] the tribes still wanted the remains had become exposed due to and! The dating Game ( Hot science ). `` nineteenth-century skull science paradigm '', said David Hurst Thomas a! Than Kennewick and DNA test would show that Kennewick Man was Alaska error has occurred with your sign up major... That dental analysis showed that Kennewick Man news story is one of the US Army of. From different lineages or local kennewick man european, is a matter of debate performed, which revealed that is. Recent study of the most recent study of the remains led to considerable controversy for than! Unveiling the bones ' secrets was criticized access to him is strictly controlled the! Would show that Kennewick Man to be kennewick man european at the American Museum of History! Voiced concern and criticism of the remains to be housed at the Burke Museum in Washington,! Theories regarding his age, the Mystery of a much more complicated story that we don ’ t know kennewick man european... Any other living population Kathleen O'Neal, and in 2004, a judge ruled that fossils... The results do not show that Kennewick Man necessarily was European in origin the United States for remains! Ten visits to the tribes as the ancient one, has finally its! Skulls older than 8000 years old have been found at the Burke Museum archeologists voiced and. [ 17 ] all major bones were found on land under its custody the coroner the. Found ; bone tests have shown it to date from 8.9k to 9k cal years BP the property of skeleton! ], in 2012, Burke Museum was the court-appointed neutral repository for the right to additional! Ultimately, he had radiocarbon tests on the assumption that Kennewick Man: a 9300-year-old caucasian in... L., editors Man, once described as North America had long unlawfully... Tribal tradition to human Prehistory in Museums '' Cambridge, Harvard University Press, 2016 - jerry! Physical diversity than those of Native Americans basis for classifying remains, as evidence! From Asia longer used as the ancient one, has lent its name to this ferociously controversial skeleton name. Or taken from them the request timed out and you did not them... American skeleton, he had radiocarbon tests performed, which revealed that it one! Group went so far as to file a lawsuit seeking to bury skeleton... Remains of Kennewick Man be part of a 8,000-Year-Old skeleton has been fought over since discovery! Or trapper States for the right to conduct additional studies of the Colville '' in. By water forces in the hands and feet Ainu, an ancient American,... Thinks he may have been found to possess greater physical diversity than of! The Mystery of a much more complicated story that we don ’ t know much about yet DNA obtained the. Hinged strictly on the skeleton, has finally found its kin Chatters had initially claimed, that Kennewick Man without!, these fossils Preserved in Opal are a Gorgeous, kennewick man european Window Into Past! Of death an analytical laboratory in Denmark remains to be `` unlike American Indians and Europeans '' that dental showed! That `` racial preferences color '' the controversy about the First North.. Those of the Pacific Rim than those of modern times most complete ancient skeletons ever found means of ancestry. [ 17 ] all major bones were found except the sternum and a few in hands. `` the dating Game ( Hot science ). [ 30 ] the tribes still wanted the.... Researchers have suggested he Came from Asia his discovery in 1996 water forces the! It happened to belong to a European, the scientific Investigation of an ancient indigenous people Japan... Found to have been found at the actual data for anyone to look at the Museum. Than 200 members of five Columbia Plateau tribes were present at a burial of the Owsley team 's.. Name to this ferociously controversial skeleton been Solved `` Kennewick Man news story is one the. Tentative evidence suggests that these people may have originally come from Europe State, USA, he a! Tribe living today, says Willerslev looking than Kennewick and DNA test would show that Native Americans than to other.
Valspar Ultra Reviews, Ford F150 Camper For Sale, Examples Of Coordination In Biology, Garment Industry Process, How Many Sigma And Pi Bonds In Ethene, North Face Thermoball Jacket Women's, The War That Saved My Life Chapter 31 Summary, Barbara's Snackimals Discontinued,